| Hour 1 |
| Why Am I So Ugly? - Denny Gudim |
| Ugly Girl - Dinks, The |
| I Need Help - Kaelin Halcrow |
| Really Bad Things - Devo Spice feat. Blythe Renay |
| Bohemian Polka - "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Bohemian Rhapsody - Muppets, The |
| I Am Terribly Important - Steve Goodie |
| People Are Still Playing D&D - D'ZasTour |
| Still Driving Cars - Tracy Schakohl |
| Peter Parker - Luke Ski feat. Sudden Death, the great |
| Ode to a Superhero - "Weird Al" Yankovic |
| Adventures of Spider-Man, The - MC Spy-D & Friends |
| Official Handbook of the Marvel Universe from A to Z, The - Tribe One |
| Thor's Big Silver Hammer - Carrie Dahlby |
| Hour 2 |
| Thanksgiving Song, The - Adam Sandler |
| I Heart Thanksgiving - Robert Lund |
| Take an Indian to Lunch This Week (Pilgrim's Progress) - Stan Freberg |
| Under the Double Turkey (The Thanksgiving Story) - Stan Freberg |
| Do Turkeys Know It's Thanksgiving? - Fibs, The |
| Eat Me I'm a Turkey - Dr. Duke Tumatoe |
| Grateful For It All - Loud House, The |
| Buy Yams...I Said - Moneyshot Cosmonauts |
| Eatin' Lotsa Turkey - Greg "Eggman" Moore |
| 'Twas the Day of Thanksgiving (Or a Visit From the Relatives) - Christopher Kent |
| Thank God Thanksgiving Only Comes Once a Year - Steve Goodie |
| Hello Kitty - Avril Lavigne |
| Tin Soldier - Roseanne Barr |
| Paralyzed - Legendary Stardust Cowboy, The |
| Hairy For You - D'Monna |
| This Time - Richard Simmons |
| Why? - Hervé Villechaize w/ Children Of The World |
| Hour 3 |
| It's Everyday Bro - Jake Paul feat. Team 10 |
| Agadoo - Black Lace |
| I Love You and You Love Me - Anthony Quinn |
| Subterranean Homesick Blues - Tom Watt |
| Deal, The - Pat Campbell |
| Big Architect, The - Duncan Johnson |
| This Pullover - Jess Conrad |
| Ooh Stick You! - Daphne & Celeste |
| Wacked-Out Five |
| (Weight's Goin') Up Down, Up Down - Cledus T. Judd |
| Liar Liar (Trump Mix) - Captain SKA |
| 1996 - Misbehavin' Maidens |
| Mr. Custer - Ted Lune |
| Wa-Elegy (Waluigi's Assist Trophy Song) - BitFinity (Matthew Taranto) |
| Fish Heads - Osaka Popstar |
| Bonus Round |
| Alice's Restaurant Massacree - Arlo Guthrie |
| Phoenix - Enzo Amore |